[return to top]
Do couples
in LDRs have
less satisfying
relationships?
Multiple studies
have measured
relationship
quality and
compared couples
in LDRs to those
in
geographically
close
relationships.
Couples in LDRs
report identical
levels of
relationship
satisfaction,
intimacy, trust,
and commitment.
[return to top]
How often
should long
distance couples
visit one
another?
This is one of
many questions
about the
demographics of
long distance
relationships,
that is, the
easily
quantifiable
parts such as
how far apart
couples live,
how often they
visit or call
one another, how
long they were
together as a
geographically
close couple
prior to having
to separate, and
so forth. I
break down long
distance
relationships
into four broad
areas –
demographics,
the personality
of each person
in the couple,
the support
system for the
relationship,
and the quality
of the
relationship
itself. Research
has shown
clearly that of
these four
components,
demographics has
the least to do
with the success
or failure of a
long distance
relationship.
Couples
therapists who
focus on long
distance
relationships
have
understandably
suggested
frequent
face-to-face
visits. Yet when
researchers
carefully looked
at this
question, the
largest and best
designed studies
found no
relationship
between how
often couples
visited one
another and how
likely they were
to stay
together. I
realize that
this seems
contrary to
common sense, so
in the book
(Long Distance
Relationships) I
discuss in more
detail each of
the studies that
looked at this
question. This
is one of
several insights
that research
has provided
that clashes
with the
opinions of many
“experts.” The
good news is
that couples
should feel free
to visit one
another however
often you can
afford to do so.
[return to top]
Do couples
in long distance
relationships
cheat on one
another more
frequently?
A common worry
among couples in
long distance
relationships is
that their
partner (or they
themselves) will
have an affair
while they’re
separated.
Common sense
suggests that
because partners
can’t keep an
eye on one
another they
might be more
prone to wander.
Researchers have
examined whether
couples in long
distance
relationships
have more
affairs than
geographically
close couples.
These studies
produced both
good news and
bad. The good
news is that all
three studies
showed that
couples in long
distance
relationships
had no greater
risk of having
an affair than
geographically
close couples.
It seems that
the risk of
having an affair
is related more
to the quality
of the
relationship
between the
couple, and the
personalities
involved, than
on mere
opportunity.
Now for the bad
news: despite
what the
statistics say,
those in long
distance
relationships
worry much more
about affairs
than those in
geographically
close
relationships.
[return to top]
What is the
most challenging
thing about long
distance
relationships?
The most
challenging
aspect of a long
distance
relationship is
maintaining the
feeling of
simply being
part of one
another’s lives.
Couples that see
one another only
once a week or
once a month
often can feel
disconnected
from their
partner. This
disconnection
can lead to an
erosion of
intimacy. Think
of intimacy as
requiring two
components: 1)
the sharing of
emotions, and 2)
inter-relatedness
of daily
activities.
Couples in long
distance
relationships
(LDRs) usually
do a great job
of sharing the
emotions that
they have for
one another. But
the second part
of the equation,
“interrelatedness”
requires a great
deal of effort.
Interrelatedness
means being
somehow involved
in your
partner’s, often
mundane,
day-to-day
activities,
adventures,
struggles, and
accomplishments.
Geographically
close couples do
this almost
unconsciously as
they chat about
little events
that are
upcoming or
recently past.
These little
events seem
relevant when
discussed right
away, but they
lose their
interest and
excitement when
discussed in
retrospect. For
example, “Guess
what happened to
me at the
grocery store?”
would be a
comment that
geographically
close couples
would share
later that
night. Although
the content may
seem trivial,
the unconscious
connection
formed between
partners with
each little
interaction,
such as this,
forms the
foundation of
intimacy. But
the same couple,
placed in a long
distance
relationship,
would likely not
think to discuss
this little
adventure at the
grocery store or
would find it
has lost it’s
interest when
brought up
several days
after the fact.
I sometimes
compare intimacy
to a rope that
holds two people
together. The
inner core of
the rope is the
sharing of
emotions between
one another. But
around this core
are thousands of
tiny fibers made
up of each
seemingly
mundane exchange
or experience
that occurs
between a
couple. While no
one fiber is
terribly
important, as a
whole they
create the true
strength of the
bond. Couples in
LDRs usually
have a great
inner core, but
by itself it
will not be
strong enough to
hold the couple
together. They
have to really
work on adding
the outer fibers
by learning how
to share in each
others world
even while
they’re apart.
[return to top]
What are the
most important
things one can
do in order to
maintain a
happy, loving
relationship
despite long
distances?
Our research
found six
critical areas
that couples
must tackle to
keep a long
distance
relationship
happy and
healthy.
1.
Stay Optimistic!
When we looked
at dozens of
coping styles
used by couples
in long distance
relationships,
the only one
that clearly
stood out was
staying
optimistic about
the
relationship.
When I work with
long distance
couples I focus
on three parts
to staying
optimistic:
Debunk the
myths, challenge
the nay-sayers,
and focus on the
positive.
Research shows
that, despite
what many people
think, LDRs do
not have any
greater chance
of breaking up
than any other
relationship.
LDRs report just
as much
satisfaction,
intimacy, trust,
and commitment
as traditional
relationships.
People in LDRs
do NOT have more
sexual affairs
than other
couples. LDRs
are NOT a “bad
idea” and, in
fact, are often
the very best
alternative of
those available.
Challenging the
nay-sayers
requires that
couples not
simply put up
with others who
tell them LDRs
“never work.”
Ask them how
they know this,
as research
shows this is
not true. We
would not put up
with someone
telling us that
our
geographically
close
relationship was
“doomed,” so
don’t let them
say the same
thing about our
LDR. Focusing on
the positive
asks couples to
remember the
advantages that
come with an LDR
(and there are
many!)
2.
Re-Learn How to
be Intimate.
This refers back
to the answer
for your first
question.
Couples in LDRs
often use their
precious time
together or on
the telephone to
share heartfelt
emotions in an
effort to bond.
But they don’t
focus on the
mundane issues
needed to feel
inter-connected
and intimate.
Our research
found that what
couples say and
how they say it
matters far more
than how
frequently they
communicate. We
use a five-step
approach to
re-learning
intimacy.
a. First, find
ways to
share in the
little
day-to-day
events.
If couples have
access to email,
send an email in
the am
discussing the
day’s plans, and
a second in the
evening telling
how everything
went. Couples
that talk
nightly need to
make sure to
talk about how
their day went
and their plans
for the next
day. Couples
with less
contact can keep
a diary of items
that they want
to share with
their partner
the next time
they do talk.
Without this,
these little
events will
vanish from
memory. Keep
track of your
partner’s events
as well so you
can ask about
them and feel a
part of them.
Some couples use
hand held tape
recorders to
“chat” with
their partner
throughout the
day. The tape is
then sent to the
partner who can
feel connected
to their
partner’s world.
Although often
couples share
deep emotions on
these tapes, the
real focus
should be
run-of-the-mill
chatter about
the day. Some
couples use
Polaroid
pictures or
digital camera
pictures to show
their partner’s
little things
that go on
during the day.
b. Second,
use technology
to create
intimacy.
Couples in
geographically
close
relationships
create intimacy
unconsciously as
they chat with
one another
while doing
other
activities. This
creates a
feeling of
“being in the
world together”
that is separate
from the
feelings shared
when two people
are wholly
focused on one
another.
Purchase a
hands-free
cordless phone
(about $50-99 in
the US). This
allows one to do
laundry or clean
up or other
chores while
talking to their
partner
simultaneously
(this is called
“parallel
communication”
in the research
world). This can
change the whole
feel of a
telephone call
and produce much
greater intimacy
in the long run.
c. Our research
found that
couples in LDRs
that stayed
together wrote
to one another
twice as often
as those that
broke up (even
when we
controlled for
differences in
trust,
commitment,
etc.)
Hand written
letters
(not email) have
an important
psychological
impact that
fosters
intimacy.
Scenting these
letters with a
particular
cologne or
perfume also can
have a profound
effect for some
couples.
d.
Understand the
pitfalls of
talking on the
telephone.
Unfortunately,
research shows
that talking on
the telephone
has a number of
important
drawbacks.
Arguments are
more difficult
to resolve,
opinions are
difficult to
predict, couples
feel
misunderstood
and attacked,
and they may
judge their
partner as less
sincere and
intelligent then
when talking
face-to-face.
Couples have to
learn to pick up
on subtle
problems that
occur while on
the telephone
and learn how to
discriminate
between problems
that result from
simply using the
telephone and
those that are
more serious.
e.
Use reminders of
your partner
frequently.
There are many
ways to keep
your partner
near
psychologically,
when they can’t
be near
physically.
Photographs are
the most
obvious, but you
can also now buy
talking
photographs in
which your
partner leaves a
digitally
recorded message
that can be
replayed with
the touch of a
button. Digital
recording key
chains are
inexpensive and
can record
several seconds
of your
partner’s voice.
More expensive
are digital
video telephones
that send a live
picture of your
partner every
few seconds
while you talk
on the
telephone. Cards
or letters with
a favorite scent
can help by
tapping into a
third sense
along with site
and sound.
[return to top]
3.
Some things must
be said.
Couples in LDRs
often don’t
discuss certain
topics that are
critical to
relationships.
Faced with
limited time
together,
couples often
don’t want to
“spoil” a
weekend by
bringing up
issues. This
leads to a
tendency to
postpone (often
indefinitely)
discussing
important
topics. Research
has shown that
while couples in
LDRs argue less
frequently than
others, they
also progress
more slowly.
Similarly,
couples in LDRs
can come to
idealize their
partner
(downplaying the
negative side)
which works well
until the couple
re-unite. Then
disillusionment
can set in. To
combat this
effect we
recommend that
couples
formalize a time
to talk about
the relationship
and address
problems that
might otherwise
fester. One
specific topic
that is often
not addressed
involves “ground
rules” about
interacting with
other people
that might be
considered a
threat to the
relationship.
For example, is
it okay to go
out with someone
for dinner? Is
it okay to go to
a movie
together? Some
dating couples
even allow for
dating other
people. In our
study we found
that about 30%
of couples who
discussed ground
rules broke up,
regardless of
whether they
decided to date
others or not.
But 70% of
couples who did
not discuss this
topic broke up.
Finally, we
remind couples
in LDRs to
generously
applaud the
contributions of
their partners.
Men in LDRs in
particular feel
that their
partners did not
acknowledge
their
contributions.
4.
Don’t Isolate
Yourself!
Research has
found that those
in LDRs very
frequently cut
themselves off
from others.
They use work as
a distraction
from the
loneliness. They
feel awkward
when they’re out
in public. Their
ambiguous status
– physically
single but not
romantically
available – can
be uncomfortable
in certain
social
situations.
Sometimes people
feel lonelier
when they’re out
in public seeing
other couples
having fun.
Frequently those
in LDRs must
focus on work
while they’re
apart in order
to have time to
spend with their
partner when
together. All of
these contribute
to a tendency to
simply turn
inward when
separated. Yet,
we know that the
degree of social
support from
friends and
family predicts
both the
emotional
difficulty
someone will
have while
separated and
the likelihood
that the
relationship
will stay
together.
Because of this
we encourage
those in LDRs to
make an effort
to spend time
with friends and
to get out and
socialize. We
also have found
that having a
confidant is
very important.
A confidant is a
friend (other
than the
romantic
partner) with
whom concerns
about the
relationship and
other important
topics can be
safely
discussed.
5.
Expect
Disappointment.
Couples in LDRs
sometimes
measure the
success of their
relationship by
the perceived
quality of the
most recent time
spent together.
If the weekend
went great then
the relationship
is doing well.
If the weekend
was a
disappointment
then the
relationship is
in trouble. All
relationships
have their ups
and downs and
geographically
close
relationships
can absorb these
ups and downs
more easily by
simply spending
more time
together.
Separated
couples
sometimes
languish in
despair or
anxiety in
between a “down”
time. Simply
realizing that
there will be
some
disappointing
times together –
and that this is
normal – will
help with those
less than
glorious
weekends.
6.
And Finally,
Learn the Art of
Long Distance
Sex.
Couples
therapists
recognize that a
couple’s sexual
experience often
parallels and
predicts the
overall
relationship
intimacy.
Fortunately,
research has
shown that
couples in LDRs
report just as
satisfying sex
lives as their
geographically
close
counterparts.
When reuniting,
couples in LDRs
often report a
“honeymoon”
effect complete
with intense and
novel sexual
escapades (one
of the
advantages of
LDRs). When
apart, couples
need to learn
how to be sexual
without being
physically
close. Usually
this involves
either telephone
sex or erotic
letters,
pictures, or
videos. In
dealing with
couples in LDRs
I’ll often
assess each
person’s comfort
with the idea of
long distance
sex. Do they
feel comfortable
talking
“erotically”
over the
telephone? Are
they comfortable
with
self-pleasuring?
If they want to
make long
distance sex
part of their
relationship
then we work on
making them more
comfortable with
these
activities. They
can start by
reading sexual
fantasies over
the telephone
(or even just to
themselves
first). There
are even books
that teach
people how to
write erotic
fantasies.
Sometimes the
sexual component
of the
relationship is
so important to
one or both
partners that
the quality of
telephone sex
can actually
make or break
the
relationship.
[return to top]
Is there
anything you
would advise
AGAINST doing?
Yes. Don’t
isolate yourself
socially. Don’t
worry about how
often you can or
can’t see one
another –
research shows
it doesn’t
matter that
much. Don’t
worry about
infidelity –
people cheat
because of
personality
issues or
problems with
the
relationship,
not because of
distance
(couples in LDRs
are no more
likely than
others to cheat
on one another).
Don’t take
advice from
others too
seriously –
there are no
“musts” in long
distance
relationships.
LDRs are more
similar to
traditional
relationships
than they are
different. Don’t
let someone tell
you that you
“must” talk to
one another
every night or
that you “must”
see each other
once a month.
The research
shows this isn’t
true.
[return to top]
Many people
stress that it
is important to
maintain
separate lives,
and not merely
sit home and
wait for the
partner to
return. Can you
explain why this
is so important?
Yes. Maintaining
separate lives
supports long
distance
relationships in
many ways. It
contributes to
being social,
which we’ve
already talked
about. It allows
one to be
productive and
to grow as a
person – one of
the great
advantages of an
LDR. Our
research found
that those in
LDRs who were in
school, for
example,
compared to
those in
geographically
close
relationships,
were generally
more successful
and found their
education more
interesting,
rewarding, and
constructive.
Thus, couples
can still have
an intimate
caring
relationship
with the one
they love, AND
they can both
develop in ways
that they
couldn’t have
otherwise.
Couples in LDRs
often talk about
something
researchers have
called
“compartmentalization.”
This refers to
psychologically
breaking their
life up into
distinct
compartments –
one the life
they have when
they’re together
with their
partner, and the
other the life
they have when
apart. When they
are separated
they move into
the “apart”
compartment and
focus on work or
self-improvement
or socializing;
thoughts about
the partner are
present but not
paramount or all
consuming. This
helps them
psychologically
deal with the
separation.
Those who just
“sit by the
phone” have not
developed an
“apart”
compartment and
they still try
to live in the
“together” world
even when
they’re not.
This uses a
tremendous
amount of
psychological
energy that
could be used in
much better
ways. When I
work with
someone who is
truly devastated
by an LDR it
often involves
teaching them
how to develop
an “apart”
compartment and
how to move away
from the
“together” world
and into this
new compartment
at appropriate
times.
[return to top]
Do you think
distance
increases
certain
problems, such
as jealousy,
misunderstandings
etc?
Yes, some
problems may be
made worse by
distance. For
example, even
though we know
that couples in
LDRs do not
cheat on one
another any more
than
geographically
close couples,
we also know
that those in
LDRs worry more
about cheating.
Because they
cannot visually
monitor their
partner in the
same way as a
geographically
close couple
can, they
sometimes create
a fantasy world
in which their
partner is
cheating. This
fantasy often
would be
dispelled in a
geographically
close
relationship as
couples monitor
one another
unconsciously or
consciously. In
an LDR this
monitoring is
far more
difficulty and
these fantasies
can get out of
hand.
Also, as I
discussed
earlier, the use
of the telephone
can increase
misunderstandings
because of the
lack of visual
cues. A vast
amount of
information is
conveyed by the
facial
expression or
hand gestures or
body position.
This is all lost
over the
telephone and a
simple comment
can be greatly
misunderstood.
Also, as we’ve
talked about
above, some
couples in LDRs
are reluctant to
discuss certain
topics for fear
of “rocking the
boat” or
“spoiling” time
together. Thus
when a topic is
misunderstood
they sometimes
will not address
this
misunderstanding
and it can
escalate into
something much
greater than it
originally had
been.
[return to top]
I understand
you have
researched the
topic widely.
Could you share
some of the
highlights of
the results you
have found?
Our research,
conducted at
Purdue
University in
Indiana, looked
at 200 couples
in LDRs and 200
couples in
geographically
close
relationships
and examined
hundreds of
different
aspects of the
relationships.
We also followed
couples in LDRs
over time to see
what contributes
to break ups
among LDRs. We
looked at people
in LDRs to see
how they coped
with separation
and to see what
psychological
effects
separation had
on them. We also
attempted to
estimate the
number of
couples in LDRs
in the U.S..
I’ve also
studied the
literature on
separated
couples over the
last 10 years
and I believe we
have the largest
collection of
research on
separated
couples in
existence. A
couple of
additional
research
highlights not
discussed above
include:
Most people in
LDRs experience
some mild
depression. This
does not seem to
improve with
time or
experience and
is probably a
type of “reflex”
reaction to
separation. The
degree of
depression is
not enough to
cause any
significant
difficulties
(such as happens
with major
depression).
Thus symptoms of
major depression
should not be
attributed
solely to the
separation and
reunion is
unlikely to
effectively
treat this
depression.
Individuals must
learn how to
address this
mild depression
rather than wait
and hope it will
go away with
time.
· The emotional
response to
separation is
relatively
constant and
predictable –
protest,
despair/depression,
detachment.
Protest can
range from a
mild, playful,
“please stay” to
significant
anger. Despair
and depression
are ubiquitous,
though mild, and
this probably
helps to prevent
people from
staying in the
“protest” phase,
which would be
generally
fruitless and
very
psychologically
tiring. The
“detachment”
phase occurs as
people move into
the “apart”
compartment that
I talked about
earlier. This is
usually a
healthy move but
sometimes people
become too
detached and are
unable to
reconnect
appropriately
when they’re
together. When
working with
couples in LDRs
I usually try to
assess each of
these three
phases to see if
there are
difficulties in
one or more and
then address
each in turn.
[return to top]
Do you have
any statistics
on the “average”
couple in a long
distance
relationship?
The following
table shows both
the average
(median)
response and the
range
of 95% of LDRs
from a sample of
over 200.
How far apart do
they live?
Average: 125
miles
95% range: 30
miles to 950
miles
How often do
they visit one
another?
Average: 1.5
times a month
95% range: once
a week to once
every four
months
How often do
they call one
another?
Average: once
every 2.7 days
95% range: at
least once a day
to once a month
How long are
their telephone
calls typically?
Average: 30
minutes
95% range: 2
minutes to 1
hour 20 minutes
How often do
they write one
another (not
including
email)?
Average: three
letters a month
95% range: never
to every other
day
How long do they
expect to be
separated before
they can move
closer to one
another?
Average: 14
months
95% Range: one
month to four
years
[return to top]